Main Street Insurance

Attica, NY – Warsaw, NY – Bell, Florida

Since 1992, Main Street Insurance has been providing professional service to customers. We have several competitive markets providing excellent coverage for personal and commercial insurance. MSI specializes in horse, farm and equine event insurance. We are licensed in NY, FL, PA, NJ, TX, GA, NC, SC & MD.

Main Street Insurance is a proud member of the Alpha Associates Inc, an insurance group of 18 professional agents represented throughout New York and Pennsylvania. We are also affiliated with ISU/Steadfast which is one of the largest and most respected insurance agency networks in the United States.

Attica, NY Office

120 Main Street / PO Box 276
Attica NY 14011
phone (585) 591-1590
fax (585) 591-1637

Sam Bennett – sam@mainstreetagency.com
Amy Meisner – amy@mainstreetagency.com
Alexis Hackmer – alexis@mainstreetagency.com
Michele Almeter – michele@mainstreetagency.com

[map & directions]

Bell, FL Office

3260 W Patton Ave. / P.O. Box 289
Bell, FL 32619

phone 352-463-1136

Katie Merle – kathryn@mainstreetagency.com
Adelaide Dun – belloffice@mainstreetagency.com

[map & directions]

Warsaw, NY Office

2407 N. Main Street
Warsaw, NY 14569

phone 585-558-1030
fax 585-591-1637

Ashli Perrigo – ashli@mainstreetagency.com 
Tommi Rutherford – Tommi@mainstreetagency.com 
Tarryn Hodge – Tarryn@mainstreetagency.com 

[map & directions]

MSI President

Linda D. Kruszka – linda@mainstreetagency.com 

Sales

Michelle Taylor
michelle@mainstreetagency.com 

Bridget Pratt
bridget@mainstreetagency.com 

Accounting

Suzanne Wheeler
suzanne@mainstreetagency.com 

Marketing

Steve Merle
belloffice@mainstreetagency.com 

General Inquiries

office@mainstreetagency.com 

Business Hours

9am-5pm EST, Monday-Thursday;
9am-4pm Friday

Contact Us

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.