We have a working relationship with the following companies,
many of which can receive payments online.
- A Central Insurance – (866) 222-2242
- Allegany Co Op – (800) 333-1679
- Allstate – (800) 336-9400
- American Bankers – (800) 245-1505
- American Collectors Insurance – (800) 360-2277
- American Equine – (847) 836-7787
- Chautauqua Patrons Insurance – (716) 664-5823 / 800-501-5787 After hours
- Dryden Mutual – (800) 556-5802 (nights and weekends)
- Erie & Niagara – (716) 632-5433
- Foremost – (800) 527-3905
- Guard – (800) 673-2465
- Hagerty Classic – (800) 747-5348
- Hanover Insurance – (800)-638-0250
- Hartford-Livestock – (800)-295-1815
- Hartford Insurance Company – (800) 962-6170
- J.C. Taylor Antique Auto – (800) 345-8290
- K&K Insurance – (800)-426-2889
- Livingston Mutual – (800)-724-0074
- Lovell Safety Group – (212) 709-8600
- Merchants Insurance – (800)-952-5246 / 888-644-6680 After hours
- Mercury Insurance – (877) 533-6330 x5000
- Millville – (800) 262-8495
- National Flood Service – (888) 637-3846
- NGM/Main Street America – (877) 425-2467
- NY Central Mutual – (800) 607-7686
- NY Property IUA – (800) 522-3372
- NYS Insurance Department – (518) 474-6600
- NYS Insurance Fund – (212) 312-9000
- Plymouth Rock – (844) 346-1225
- Preferred Mutual – (800) 333-7642
- Progressive – (800) 274-4499
- Progressive Commercial – (800) 274-4499
- Selective Flood – (877) 348-0552
- Sterling – (800) 462-4661
- Travelers – (800) 252-4633
- Travelers Commercial – (800) 238-6225